EdChoice Launches Choice Comparison: A Comprehensive Site for ESA Program Design, Comparison, and Access

Create your own ESA program, compare it to other states, and gain insights into effective policy design

As education reform gains momentum, Education Savings Accounts (ESAs) are at the center of policy innovation. To support informed decision-making and effective ESA program development, EdChoice has introduced Choice Comparison—a one-stop platform featuring tools for policy comparison, bill creation, and resource access for parents and vendors. 

A Resource for Policymakers, Parents, and Vendors 

Choice Comparison provides a robust set of tools for policymakers, analysts, parents, and vendors: 

• Policy Comparison Tools: Compare ESA programs and policies across states, allowing users to gain a clear understanding of how their state measures up in terms of funding, eligibility, and structure. 

• Bill Builder Tool: Design a custom ESA program tailored to your state’s needs. This tool allows users to select specific factors, generating a complete bill draft with language adapted from current ESA programs nationwide. 

• Resources for Parents and Vendors: Access clear steps for applying for ESA funds, including application links, eligibility information, and vendor guidelines to help families and service providers navigate the ESA landscape. 

Comparing ESA Programs Across States 

One of the tool’s unique features is its ability to compare ESA programs from different states. Policymakers frequently ask, “How does our ESA program measure up to other states?” With the ESA Builder, users can explore how other states structure their ESA programs, including funding levels, eligibility, and overall scope. This information can be invaluable for legislators and their teams, helping them understand existing policies and design programs that meet or exceed national standards. 

Inputs for Program Design 

The ESA Builder allows users to customize their ESA program by selecting specific policy components from existing state programs. Users can choose from various options for each component, such as: 

• Program Design: Program design options include selecting the fund administrator, funding mechanism, and disbursement frequency as well as setting an application window and specifying whether unused funds can roll over each year. 

• Eligibility: Eligibility requirements can include income limits, requiring prior public school attendance, and geographic restrictions. Other options include compatibility for homeschool students and testing requirements for participants. 

• Authorized Use of Program Funds: Authorized uses for program funds might cover school tuition, tutoring, special needs therapies, textbooks, and even college savings in some cases. 

By selecting options for each of these components, users can craft a personalized ESA program that aligns with their state’s objectives and requirements. 

Output and Insights 

After users configure their ESA program using the Builder, the tool generates a comprehensive bill draft with language drawn from existing ESA programs, customized based on the factors selected. This output provides policymakers with ready-to-use legislative language, offering a practical starting point to develop effective ESA legislation for their state. 

“The ESA Builder provides a one-stop shop for policymakers and partners to compare existing ESA programs, access suggested language, and even build new ones. It’s designed to give users the best research and practical support for crafting stronger, more effective legislation for their states,” said Nathan Sanders, a Policy and Advocacy Director at EdChoice. 

Limitations and Considerations 

While the ESA Builder is a robust resource, it’s essential to understand its scope. The tool provides foundational information to support ESA design and analysis but does not replace comprehensive fiscal impact assessments that factor in each state’s unique budgetary structure. Instead, it’s intended as a comparative tool for high-level program design, offering a useful starting point for discussions about ESA development and policy. 

Your Feedback Matters 

We’re excited to offer this resource and are committed to continuously improving it based on feedback. Have questions or suggestions? We’d love to hear from you! Contact your local EdChoice representative. We hope this tool proves invaluable in creating ESA programs that support students, families, and educators across the country.  

Explore Choice Comparison and start designing your program today.